The myth of uniqueness: why a website unlike any other may not be the best idea
‘Make us a website that will disrupt the market. We want something absolutely unique that nobody has seen before.’ This is one of the most dangerous requests a web studio manager can hear. Clients fear blending in with competitors and pursue visual exclusivity at any cost. Yet perception works differently: when something is easy to use, people barely notice. When it is inconvenient, they may leave for a competitor in three seconds. In pursuit of originality, businesses often sacrifice both money already invested and potential revenue. According to Forrester Research, a well-designed interface can increase conversion by up to 200%.
What is the article about
Uniqueness for its own sake almost always reduces that figure.
Why the brain likes familiarity: Jakob’s Law
A fundamental design principle, Jakob’s Law, says that users spend most of their time on other websites.
This means they prefer your site to work like the other sites they already know.
For example
The cart should be an icon in the top-right corner.
Clicking the logo in the header should lead to the home page.
The phone number in the header should be clickable.
If you put the Buy button at the bottom center of the page simply because it feels fresh, you make the visitor think. Every extra moment of uncertainty increases the chance they will leave.
Your job as a business is not to surprise people with graphics, but to sell a product with as little effort from the customer as possible.
What patterns are and why they matter
UX patterns are time-tested solutions to common problems. They are not copies of someone else’s design, but established ways for people to interact with an interface.
Progressive disclosure
Do not dump every feature on users at once. Show only what is relevant now. During registration, for example, request information in stages. Research suggests this reduces cognitive load by 30–40%. Nike uses this approach: one question per screen.
Inline validation
More than 70% of e-commerce purchases are abandoned at checkout because of form errors. A better approach is to flag a problem as the user types—for example, ‘Password is too short’—instead of presenting a list after they click Pay. It saves frustration and money.
Microinteractions
Small details make a site feel alive and polished: a button subtly changes color on hover, a form field softly highlights on focus, or a loading indicator appears. These details subconsciously confirm the user’s actions. They can increase audience retention by up to 30%, but do not overdo them: excessive animation irritates 60% of users.
The price of ‘unique’ design: lower conversion
When a studio follows a client’s wish to be unlike everyone else, three problems arise:
Breaking the design system. Instead of using ready-made components that have already been tested and work quickly, developers must write custom code from scratch. This costs more and takes longer.
Slower performance. Complex nonstandard animations and scripts make pages heavier. Google ranks slow sites lower in search results.
Higher maintenance costs. A year later, a new designer or developer may spend twice as long understanding the custom logic behind your unique product filter.
How to balance brand and usability
You can and should be unique, but in the right places:
Use familiar infrastructure
navigation, cart, customer account and search form.
Be distinctive in your content
your copy, product photos, tone of voice and unique selling proposition set you apart, not the location of your logo.
Innovate in your service
add a feature others lack, such as an advanced price calculator or AR try-on, but make it as predictable as possible for users to start.
Before asking a designer to ‘break the internet’, ask yourself whether you are willing to sacrifice 15–20% of conversions just to hear a customer say, ‘Wow, I have never seen that before.’ The answer often determines the project’s fate.
Let us turn your wishes into technical requirements.
Send us your project goals and we will give you a budget range by the end of the working day.